New Government Program To Aid Short Sales - Even in Marin County!
A new government program may make it easier for homeowners to sell their house for less than they owe, known as a short sale.
The Treasury Department said it is creating a streamlined, industrywide process for short sales, and will even pay bonuses to certain borrowers, loan servicers, and second-lien holders who do them.
The plan will “provide incentives for servicers and borrowers to pursue short sales” when the borrower is generally eligible for loan modification under the Making Homes Affordable plan, but either can’t qualify (for example, due to job loss) or they have had the loan modified, but now can keep up the payments.
Treasury will pay a servicer $1,000 for completing a successful short sale, the borrower $1,500 to assist with relocation expenses, and the second lien-holder who releases claims up to $1,000. Details can be found here.
This is good news for lots of distressed sellers out there right now, and good news for the banks also. Short sales are generally better for everyone, I believe, than foreclosure, for three reasons.
1. Short sales typically sell at a higher value than foreclosures. So by selling short and taking a relatively small loss now rather than a big one later, the lender will usually get more for the house.
Foreclosures definitely carry a stigma with them, and are often in terrible shape. People who are losing their home have no incentive to take care of them, are often angry, and the condition of the home shows it. Looking at foreclosed homes can often be a very depressing experience, and the pricing reflects that.
2. Short sales are better for home values in the neighborhood. As noted, foreclosures carry a stigma and a big discount, and that sale becomes a comp for the neighborhood. Short sales will be at a discount also, but without all of the emotional trauma, overgrown lawns, etc.
3. Short sales are usually better for the owner. From a credit perspective, most experts believe a short sale is better than a foreclosure. Sellers should absolutely consult an attorney and a CPA however, because some also believe foreclosure may be a better option. In California, if the lender wants to come after you for the unpaid balance (always check that when you get the approval!) and you have never refinanced, you may be better off. That’s because in California, a loan used to buy a primary residence is non-recourse debt. So if the lender does foreclose, they cannot go after other assets.
Short sales in Marin County are quickly becoming more common beyond San Rafael and Novato, where we have seen many in the past two years. We are now seeing short sales in Larkspur, Corte Madera, Mill Valley, even Tiburon. One closed last week in fact in Tiburon, for $1.9 Million. Asking price was $2.495 Million, so that gives you an idea of what kind of discounts may be out there. Let’s hope this program is effective at helping to move these distressed sales through the system, so we can get back to a normal market!
![]()
